The Best Pickleball Paddles: MTEN, Niupipo, JOOLA, GAMMA, and Selkirk Compared
- Fred & Ellis
- Feb 5
- 8 min read
Updated: 1 day ago
Pickleball has exploded in popularity, and with so many paddle options available, choosing the right one can feel overwhelming. At Fred & Ellis, we’ve scoured Amazon reviews to break down the pros and cons of the best pickleball paddles in 2025. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned player, this guide will help you find the perfect paddle.
MTEN Pickleball Set
Dimensions: 15.67"L x 7.8"W
Grip Size: 4.57 inches
Weight: 2.2 Pounds
Amazon Rating: 4.8 / 5 (as of April 2025)
The MTEN Pickleball Paddle combines advanced materials and thoughtful design for a paddle that’s perfect for players of all levels. With a fiberglass face and a polypropylene honeycomb core, it offers excellent durability, control, and a smooth feel on every shot. The lightweight construction ensures quick reactions, while the comfortable grip reduces hand fatigue for longer play sessions. Whether you’re playing casually or in a competitive match, this paddle provides a great balance of power and precision.
Positive Reviews:
User A:"Excellent starter set to get into the game of pickleball... Tough paddles, regulation balls and a nice carrying case for it all! I have recommended this to everyone who is thinking about playing - the barrier to entry for the cost is so low that no one should have an excuse not to play! Get out there and whack some balls!" (5 Stars)
User B: “The paddles have been great, I was using since last 2 months and have no complaints about it. The balls are also very good indoor as well as outdoor. The most interesting thing about these paddles is the design is very classy apart from great strength and grip that come with it. Totally worth the money.” (5 Stars)
Negative Reviews:
User C: "The paddles are great; perfect for a beginner like me but the carrying bag is a very tight fit for both paddles and 4 balls. I ended up having to order a larger bag." (3 stars)
User D:"The set comes well packaged and case and racket looks great. However the racket lacks power." (3 Stars)
Niupipo Pickleball Rackets Set
Dimensions: 10.71"L x 7.8"W
Grip Size: 4 4/5 inch
Weight: 1.5 Pounds
Amazon Rating: 4.7 / 5 (as of April 2025)
Designed for players who value a balance of power and control, the Niupipo Pickleball Paddle features a lightweight fiberglass face and a polypropylene honeycomb core. This combination provides a responsive feel with reduced vibrations, making it an excellent choice for both beginners and seasoned players. The cushioned grip ensures comfort during extended play, while the USAPA approval means it’s ready for competitive matches.
Positive Reviews:
User E: "This is a great paddle for someone getting started and a good backup paddle for an intermediate player. It's made of the same materials and construction methods as some of the higher-priced paddles. If you're a beginner and you don't want to be stuck with the drawbacks of some of the clunky beginner paddles, it's a great one to start with. I 'm intermediate, and I bought it as a backup paddle in case the one I usually play with gets damaged, lost etc. Also, it's nice to have a second paddle in case a friend who's new to the sport wants to try it with you." (5 Stars)
User F: "The USAPA approval means they meet the highest standards for play, ensuring a fair and competitive experience. The lightweight fiberglass construction paired with the polypropylene honeycomb core provides the perfect balance of control and power, allowing me to execute precise shots without straining my arms during long matches." (5 Stars)
Negative Reviews:
User G: "The paddles come in a nice carrying case. Using the paddle for the first time, there are little specs of paint coming off of the paddle. Handle is nice but for a woman I wish they were a little smaller in diameter." (3 Stars)
User H: "I love everything about this paddle, light weight, cushioned grip, just the right length and the beautiful purple design. But it has a fiberglass face, which causes such a loud ping sound whenever the ball hits the paddle. and therefore I need to send it back and trade it for something without glass." (3 Stars)
JOOLA Ben Johns Pickleball Set
Dimensions: 22"L x 7.5"W
Grip Size: 4 1/2 inches
Weight: 2 Pounds
Amazon Rating: 4.6 / 5 (as of April 2025)
Backed by professional player Ben Johns, this JOOLA paddle is built for those who demand high performance on the court. The fiberglass face delivers excellent spin and precision, while the Response Honeycomb Polymer Core enhances power without sacrificing control. With a premium grip for a secure hold and an optimized weight balance, this paddle is a solid option for competitive players aiming to elevate their game.
Positive Reviews:
User I: "I recently got my hands on the JOOLA Ben Johns Pickleball Set, and I have to say, I’m pretty impressed! I’ve been playing pickleball for a while now, but this set really took things up a notch for me. If you’re looking for a paddle that feels sturdy but not too heavy, this might be the one. Now, I’ll be honest, this set is a little pricier than some other beginner options, but you really get what you pay for here. The durability and performance make it worth the extra cost, especially if you’re serious about improving your game. I can see this set lasting me for a long time, and I’m excited to keep using it." (5 Stars)
User J: "Nice grips and light paddles easy to hold. This is our first pickleball set. Love the storage bags to keep everything together." (5 Stars)
Negative Reviews:
User K: "The paddle so far is great for the price. However I only used the set for a few games and the outdoor ball broke during regular use. Hopefully the paddles don’t prove to be that brittle. But so far it’s pretty good." (3 Stars)
User L: "Paddle is durable and that’s about the only good thing I would say. Can spend $30 for a pair exactly the same just a different brand name. Good starter but I’d go even cheaper for the same quality." (3 Stars)
GAMMA Sports Fusion Pro Pickleball Paddles Set
Dimensions: One size
Grip Size: 4 inches
Weight: 2.64 pounds
Amazon Rating: 4.9 / 5 (as of April 2025)
Engineered for players who want durability and consistency, the GAMMA paddle features a composite hitting surface paired with a polymer core for excellent touch and power. Its textured face helps generate spin, while the cushioned grip provides comfort for all-day play. Whether you're a beginner or an experienced player, this paddle is designed to keep up with your game.
Positive Reviews:
User M: "If you're looking to step up your game, this is your set. The honeycomb / graphite face paddles have that crisp feel you didn't know you were missing. Everything about this set is next level from the premium grips to the custom bag will help step up your game. I grew up playing traditional tennis and have recently gotten into Pickleball. I love the fact I can purchase an entire premium set of gear like this with a great bag for a third of the price of the last tennis racquet i picked up." (5 Star)
User N: "I am so impressed by the quality of this set! I just recently got into Pickleball with one of my good friends, and I needed some of my own paddles. This came with such a nice backpack, the type that will last for literal years. The strap on the backpack is padded and the back of it has padding as well, so it’s really comfortable. The zippers are really high-quality. There is also a side drink holder to carry your water bottle." (5 Stars)
Negative Reviews:
User O: "I just wish they had used better quality zippers and lining material on the bag. I’m sure it will last a while, but it could have been slightly better with thicker lining and YKK zippers." (5 Stars)
User P: "While the set is undeniably impressive, my only minor gripe lies with the quality of the balls – the two-piece molded construction feels a tad rough to the touch. However, this minor setback does not diminish my overall satisfaction with the set." (5 Stars)
2024 Selkirk LUXX Control Pickleball Paddle
Dimensions: 16.45"L x 7.5" W
Grip Size: 4 1/4 inches
Weight: 0.48 Pounds
Amazon Rating: 4.6 (as of April 2025)
Selkirk is known for high-quality paddles, and this model is no exception. Featuring a polypropylene honeycomb core and a durable fiberglass face, it delivers a great mix of power and control. The EdgeSentry guard adds extra durability, while the comfortable grip ensures stability in every shot. Ideal for players seeking precision and a reliable paddle for competitive play.
Positive Reviews:
User Q: "I've progressed in my Pickleball skills from 4 previous paddles to this Selkirk Iuxx paddle. This is an outstanding paddle. My play with this Selkirk paddle has elevated me one level in ratings! Even my friends have noticed my increased performance with the Selkirk paddle. The paddle feels lightweight in my hand, yet the ball responds in terrific control and accuracy. I love this paddle!" (5 Stars)
User R: “perfect for me, a bit pricey, but after researching many this one seems to fit me best. I have tremendous spin in tennis, and I buy my rackets and strings to fit my spin so i decided to do the same with my paddle. It works. Love the spin, the feel, the reach. Good buy!” (5 Stars)
Negative Reviews:
User S: "I’m a solid 4.0 player, I’ve owned and played with dozens of paddles. Too be fair I only played with this for two days but it seriously lacked in terms of a sweet spot. A lot more power than I expected for a 20mm paddle. Looks amazing in blue. Had to return." (3 Star Rating)
User T: "There was a lot I liked about this paddle. If it were available in a different grip shape and smaller, I would have exchanged rather than returned it after a week of using it. The grip shape didn’t suit me, and the girth of it was too big." (3 Star Rating)
F&E Verdict
Each paddle has its strengths and weaknesses, but here’s how they stack up:
Best Budget Pick: MTEN Pickleball Paddles – A fantastic choice for beginners at a great price. Amazon Rating: 4.8 / 5 based on 4,192 ratings (as of April 2025)
Best for Control and Power: Niupipo Pickleball Paddles – Ideal for intermediate players looking for a balance of power and precision.
Amazon Rating: 4.7 / 5 based on 7,961 ratings (as of April 2025)
Best for Beginners & Comfort: JOOLA Ben Johns Pickleball Set – Great for new players who want a lightweight, wrist-friendly paddle. Amazon Rating: 4.7 / 5 based on 495 ratings (as of April 2025)
Best Overall Quality: GAMMA Sports Fusion Pro Pickleball Paddles – Excellent craftsmanship with superior control. Amazon Rating: 4.9 / 5 based on 20 ratings (as of April 2025)
Best Premium Paddle: 2024 Selkirk LUXX Control Pickleball Paddle – Perfect for advanced players who want the best performance, though it comes at a premium price. Amazon Rating: 4.6 based on 327 ratings (as of April 2025)
Whichever paddle you choose, Fred & Ellis recommends considering your playstyle, experience level, and budget before making a purchase. Happy playing!
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This site contains Amazon affiliate links. Product ratings and review counts mentioned in this post were accurate at the time of publishing but may change over time. Please check Amazon directly for the most up-to-date information.
This post was crafted with the assistance of advanced AI technology to analyse and compile insights from Amazon customer reviews. By leveraging AI, F&E ensure a comprehensive and unbiased assessment of the products discussed, providing you with accurate and reliable information.
Comments